For Remove and Lift, I’d also expect the entire selection to be removed or lifted.
For Replace, would there be any use case where a bunch of timeline clips need to be replaced with a single source clip? I haven’t had that kind of need yet.
This is fixed as well as Remove and Lift. However, if you have multiple selected and choose Remove from a blank spot’s context menu, it only removes the blank. A blank spot and its context menu is a little special as blank is not a member of selection.
Alt Up/Down are used to switch between & play clips in the play list (on linux )
What about extending Alt - Left/Right to also stop at markers (start/end) besides cuts as it does now ?
Maybe that shortcut could be changed to something else. Alt has sort of been established to be the key to seek. It’s used to seek clips, to seek simple keyframes and to drag the playhead without holding the left mouse button. It’d be a good idea to maintain that consistency.
And it’s better to have a separate shortcut to seek to just the markers for the purposes of placement and to make cuts and such.
@brian, would it be possible to move the color option menu from the Marker Edit menu to the right click menu? I suggest this because I see that it takes about 5 clicks to go to two menus to change a color of one marker. If someone wants to mark down several markers and make them all different colors then it would end up being a lot of clicking. If changing a color can be moved to the right click menu under Edit then that it’d a much quicker process and a lot less clicking.
One way to reduce the number of clicks is to use the keyboard shortcuts:
1: Press “M” to create the marker
2: Press “M” again to open the edit dialog
3: Press “TAB” to move focus to the “Color” button
4: Press “Enter” to open the color dialog
5: Use mouse to select color in the dialog
6: Press “Enter” to accept the color selection and close the color dialog
7: Press “TAB” 3 times to move focus to the “OK” button
8: Press “Enter” to apply the color change
Changing the color can be done with 9 key strokes and one mouse movement.
It might be a little late for this, but there is also the opportunity to use a set of preset colors only, listed in a menu. Then, I saw in another tool when choosing to export chapters, you choose the color of markers to export.
I also took a look at the color bug when switching layouts and restoring from minimized, and it is very strange. It affects all platforms regardless of display method. It even affects Intel macOS, which uses a different version of Qt. Furthermore, timeline reload (F5) does not work. I tried a number of workarounds and could not get anything to work. The only workaround at the moment is to save and reopen the project. We might need to convert the marker to use a different Qt technology as this is our first time using a somewhat new technology. There are 2 other ways I know to draw this. I do kind of feel this is a bad bug because when it is not a range, then it can be a totally false color.
Awesome work with the new markers, especially the export part is a really nice touch I never knew I wanted.
Are there any plans of implementing some sort of ripple logic to them? I wanted to use them to sort of separate different “chapters” of subclips in my video but then I removed a longer clip at the start of the project and everything was misplaced.
Of course, some people might want the opposite (to just have them fixed in place) so some sort of toggle would be necessary.
And while we’re on the subject, what do you guys think of having the ability to change the color of the clip in timeline? This would complement the markers quite well as they’d pefectly follow the ripple/trim logic already estabilished. It could be as simple as Right click → Color → (choose from something like 5 classic predefined colors and a custom option).
Oh, I just noticed there’s a long separate thread discussing the ripple thing. Nevermind that part then.