Multicam editing

I know this topic comes up from time to time but wondered where there were any update techniques. I often use two cameras for my projects. Same event, two different views. I’ve mostly done picture-in-picture rather than a multicam scene switch.

Since AFAIK, ShotCut does not have multicam capability, the technique I’ve seen that seems to make the most sense to scene switch seems to be (after syncing the two tracks)

  1. Main video on Track 2
  2. “Switch to” video on Track 1.
  3. An invisible Track 3.

Split out pieces of Track 2 as needed and move them to Track 3. You can delete them, but saving them in Track 3 lets you make changes.

Does this technique still make sense or are there better options? Any good tutorials?

I recently did a 4-camera edit for a wedding, and I’m still using the workflow below. Works great.

The approach you’re using is fine for two sources. A single invisible track doesn’t work for 3+ sources, hence the method below.

Thank you. I had been using Size and Position to view both tracks or produce a Picture in Picture. But I’m playing with switching. Thanks for the confirmation and adaptation to even more cameras.

As a confirmation since I realize my last post was not very detailed… the 2x2 video wall I described using Size and Position filters to edit with four sources is only for preview. Once the cuts are finalized, the Size and Position track filters are disabled. At that point, only one track makes it to the final output at a time, effectively becoming a switcher. I can re-enable the filters if I ever need to trim, cut, or replace clips again.

Yes, while I was using Size/Position/Rotate in my final, I understood that you were using it as a way to select which track to use for a particular segment.

The one thing I don’t understand is the use of Ripple All Tracks. I know if I delete a segment from a multi-track project it will have the effect of removing the equivalent piece of the rest of the tracks, syncing everything without having to split those as well, but here, where, the only thing you are removing is a piece of a single track, keeping everything else the same, I don’t see it’s purpose.

Aside from that, again, thank you. The flow works quite well.

​​​​​​​

Ripple All Tracks is for keeping all tracks in sync when dead air is removed from a long clip. Ripple is turned off when it’s time to select which track makes it to the output by cutting away higher tracks. Sorry for the confusion.

Aligning on a clap proves sync only at that instant. Worth checking the far end of the longest take too: two cameras do not share one clock, so drift shows up late. How long were your longest takes?

Building on the sync-drift point above: if you do find drift at the far end, a practical fix is to split the long take into shorter sections and re-align each section to the same reference sound, rather than stretching the whole clip. Also check before editing whether any camera recorded with a variable frame rate — converting that clip to a constant frame rate first often removes a steady drift that otherwise keeps reappearing, no matter how carefully the start is aligned.

All good points regarding drift. In my case, I was able to use all Panasonic cameras for my 4-camera wedding shoot. Given their similar hardware, their drift (with no external timecode generation) was so non-existent after 1.5 hours that the postlude music didn’t even phase when tracks were stacked. I was able to edit the full program with a single audio sync at the beginning. That’s one of the perks of using dedicated cameras instead of a smartphone.

Fortunately, drift has not been a big issue. It was when I first got started, mostly because if different rates between my video and separately recorded audio. But I was able to adjust the audio in audacity enough to compensate. Drift has occurred, but that just meant small realignments later on

To answer your question, I use my cameras to record in the cockpit of a small airplane. So we’re talking about a few hours of continuous recording, but what I end up ans viewable (interesting) has never been more than 15 minutes.